Ciladda Homeopathic ee Khatarta?
Sidoo kale loo yaqaan ' Anas barbariae hepatitis' iyo Cordis extractum 200 c , Oscillococcinum waa daaweyn loo yaqaan 'homeopathic treatment' oo loo isticmaalo daaweynta hargabka .
Iyadoo lagu saleynayo aragtida ah "sida daaweynta sida," homeopathy wuxuu ujeedkiisu yahay in lagu daweeyo jirrooyinka isaga oo bixinaya qiyaas yar oo ka mid ah walxaha soo saara calaamadaha astaamaha cudurka la daweynayo. Marka loo eego falsafada guryaha, daawooyinkaas aadka loo qafiifiyey waxay kicin karaan qaababka jirka ee is-jirka.
Oscillococcinum waxaa laga sameeyaa xayawaanka dareenka wadnaha iyo beerka, taas oo loo yaqaan 'homeopaths' aaminsan yihiin inay yihiin kaydka fayruuska hargabka. Caawinta waxaa la diyaariyaa iyada oo la isticmaalayo 200 dil. Isku darka ugu horreeya wuxuu ka kooban yahay 1% ka mid ah nuugidda duck, isku dar walbana wuxuu ka kooban yahay 1% isku dar ah, darajada saddexaad waxay ka kooban tahay 1% isku dhafka labaad, iyo wixii la mid ah illaa 200 oo jeer lagu qasi karo.
Gargaarka Caafimaadka
Inkasta oo tiro yar oo cilmi-baaris ah ay soo jeedinayaan in Oscillococcinum ay leedahay saameyn wax ku ool ah dadka qaba hargabka, ma jiraan wax caddayn ah in daaweyntu ay ka hortagi karto ifilada ama u adeegto sida daaweynta koowaad ee fayruska. Halkan fiiri dhowr natiijooyin waxbarasho:
- Sannadkii 2007 oo ka mid ah toddoba daraasadood oo ku saabsan daweyn dhamaystiran oo ku saabsan daaweynta ama ka hortagga hargabka, cilmi-baarayaasha ayaa helay "qaar ka mid ah xogta dhiirigelisa" ee isticmaalka Oscillococcinum. Si kastaba ha ahaatee, dib u eegista ayaa soo gabagabeysay "in waxtarka daaweyn kasta oo daaweyn ama ka hortag ah lagu daaweeyo ama looga hortago hargabka xilliyeed aan la helin shaki macquul ah."
- Dib-u-eegis lagu daabacay 2006-dii, ka dibna la soo dhaafay 2009, aqoonyahaniintu waxay xoojiyeen todoba daraasadood (oo ay ka mid yihiin wadarta 3,459 ka qayb-galayaal) waxayna ogaadeen in daaweynta Oscillococcinum ay hoos u dhigtay dhererka jirrada hargabka illaa 0.28 maalmood. Ma jirin wax caddayn ah in Oscillococcinum ay ka hortagi karto hargabka.
- Dib-u-eegid kale oo cilmi-baaris ah, oo la daabacay 2005-kii, baarayaasha ayaa go'aamiyay in caansanaanta Oscillococcinum aan la taageerin caddaynta sayniska.
Qabashada
Maaddaama ay aad u badhxan yihiin, daaweynta miyir-qaadashada sida Oscillococcinum ayaa u muuqda inaanay saameyn xun ku yeelan. Xaaladaha qaarkood, si kastaba ha noqotee, bukaanku si kooban ayuu u dareemi karaa ka dib markii uu marka hore bilaabmayo daaweynta guriga loo yaqaan 'homeopathic treatment'.
Iyadoo ay jirto khatarta hoose ee saameynta daawooyinka, waxaa muhiim ah in taxadar laga qaado marka la isticmaalo Oscillococcinum daaweynta hargabka. Sababtoo ah fayruska ifilada wuxuu u horseedi karaa dhibaatooyin sida oof-wareen (xaalad halis ah oo nafta halis gelineysa), waa inaad raadsataa daaweyn haddii aad leedahay calaamadaha hargabka sida qufaca, dhuun xanuun, murqo xanuun, daal, madax-xanuun, iyo qandho sare.
Isticmaalka Oscillococcinum
Sababtoo ah la'aanta cilmi-baarista taageerada, waa mid aad u dhakhso badan oo ku-talinta Oscillococcinum ee hargabka. Cabbiraadaha looma baarin nabadgelyo iyo sababtoo ah xaqiiqada ah in cuntada dheellitirka badanaa aan loo qoondeeynin, waxyaabaha ka mid ah alaabooyinka qaarkood way ka duwanaan karaan waxa ku qoran calaamadda badeecada. Sidoo kale maskaxda ku hay in badbaadada dheeraadka ah ee haweenka uurka leh, hooyooyinka kalkaaliyaha, carruurta, iyo kuwa qaba xaaladaha caafimaad ama kuwa qaadanaya daawooyinka aan la dhicin.
Haddii aad ka fekereyso isticmaalka guriga loo yaqaan 'homeopathy', la hadal dhakhtarkaaga koowaad. Is-daweynta xaalad iyo iska ilaalinta ama dib u dhigida daryeelka caadiga ah waxay yeelan kartaa cawaaqib culus.
> Ilo:
> Guo R, Pittler MH, Ernst E. "Daawo Dheeraad ah oo Lagu Daweeyo ama Ka Hortago Hargabka ama Cudurka Hurgunka Leh." Am J Med. 2007 120 (11): 923-929.e3.
> van der Wouden JC, Bueving HJ, Poole P. "Ka Hortagga Hargabka: Guudmarka Aragti Baadhitaan." Respir Med. 2005 99 (11): 1341-9.
> Vickers A, Smith C. "Oslo-oocoska" Homo-Psychiatry Oscillococcinum ee ka hortagga iyo daaweynta hargabka iyo astaamaha jilicsan. "Database Syst Rev. 2009 8; (3): CD001957.